Best Breast Pump for Working Moms: Top 8 Recommendations for 2024

Breastfeeding is a vital aspect of nurturing a child, yet for working moms, it often presents unique challenges that can feel overwhelming. Balancing the demands of a career with the commitment to breastfeeding can lead to stress, frustration, and feelings of inadequacy. From finding the right breast pump to navigating workplace policies and personal emotional hurdles, many working mothers struggle to maintain their breastfeeding journey while fulfilling professional responsibilities.

This article explores the obstacles faced by working moms, essential factors for selecting the best breast pump, different types of pumps available, expert tips for managing pumping at work, and ways to deal with milk undersupply.

Challenges Faced by Working Moms in Breastfeeding

For working moms, balancing breastfeeding with job responsibilities can be incredibly tough. Limited time for pumping and lack of private spaces often lead to stress and frustration. Many workplaces don’t offer supportive environments, making it challenging to maintain a consistent pumping routine. High-stress jobs can reduce milk supply, while fatigue from juggling work and nighttime feedings adds to their struggles. Traveling for work complicates milk storage and pumping even further. Choosing a suitable breast pump that fits their needs can also be daunting. Despite these challenges, working moms persist with resilience, striving to provide for their babies while managing their professional lives.

Essential Factors for Selecting the Best Breast Pump for Working Moms

For working moms, finding the right breast pump isn’t just about convenience; it’s about making the breastfeeding journey manageable alongside a busy career. Here are some key factors to consider that can make all the difference:

• Portability: A compact, lightweight pump is easier to carry and ideal for pumping on the go, whether during commutes or in between meetings.
• Suction Strength: Strong and adjustable suction levels ensure efficient milk expression, helping moms pump faster and maximize their short break times.
• Battery Life: A long battery life is a must for working moms who need to pump throughout the day. Choose a pump with a rechargeable battery that can last several sessions between charges, giving you flexibility and reducing the need for constant recharging.
• Comfort: Pumps with customizable, comfortable flanges help reduce discomfort, making frequent pumping sessions more manageable and less of a strain.
• Noise Control: A quiet pump provides much-needed privacy, allowing moms to pump discreetly without drawing attention in workplace settings.
• Double Pumping Option: Double pumps save valuable time, allowing moms to express milk from both breasts simultaneously—ideal for those short on time.
• Easy to Clean: Pumps with fewer parts and simple assembly make cleaning easier and quicker, so moms spend less time on maintenance and more time on what matters most.

Understanding the different types of breast pumps

There are several types of breast pumps, each suited to different needs and lifestyles. Here’s a brief overview of the most common types and the pros and cons of each to help working moms choose the right option.

1. Manual Pumps

Manual pumps are hand-operated ones that require the user to manually press a lever or handle to create suction and express milk.

Pros: Lightweight, portable, affordable, and quiet; ideal for occasional use or quick sessions.

Cons: Requires hand operation, which can be tiring and time-consuming.

Best For: Moms who only need to pump occasionally or are looking for a budget-friendly backup option.

2. Double Electric Pumps

Double electric pumps use power (either from an outlet or battery) to pump milk from both breasts simultaneously, offering efficient and hands-free operation.

Pros: Efficient and powerful, allowing simultaneous pumping from both breasts; ideal for saving time during breaks.

Cons: Usually more expensive and can be bulky; may require access to an outlet.

Best For: Moms who need to pump frequently and want to maximize milk output in limited time, such as during work breaks.

3. Wearable Pumps

Wearable Pumps are designed to be worn inside a bra, allowing moms to pump discreetly while performing other tasks.

Pros: Discreet and hands-free, fitting inside a bra for on-the-go pumping; offers flexibility to pump at a desk or while commuting.

Cons: Typically less powerful than electric pumps; may have a smaller milk storage capacity.

Best For: Busy moms who need a flexible, discreet option for pumping while multitasking.

Top 8 Breast Pumps for Professional Mothers

Choosing the right breast pump is essential for working mothers who want to maintain a breastfeeding routine while managing a busy work schedule. Below are the top eight breast pumps, categorized by their core features, ensuring every working mom finds the perfect fit for her needs.

Best Wearable & Electric Breast Pumps for Working Moms：

1. Willow 3.0 (Willow 360)

The Willow 3.0, or Willow 360, empowers modern moms with the freedom to pump anywhere and in any position, breaking traditional limitations.

• Freedom to Pump in Any Position: With a 100% leak-proof latch and 360-degree mobility, you can pump comfortably while moving around, whether at home or on the go.
• Strong, Spill-Free Performance: Featuring patented Continuous Latch technology, this pump provides hospital-grade suction for efficient milk expression without any spills, ensuring you won’t lose a drop.
• Compact Design with Extended Battery Life: Lightweight and portable, the rechargeable battery lasts up to five pumping sessions, making it perfect for busy workdays and outings.
• Convenient Apple Watch Compatibility: Easily control your pumping sessions and track progress directly from your wrist, adding convenience to your daily routine.

2. Elvie Stride Hospital-Grade App-Controlled Breast Pump

The Elvie Stride is a hospital-grade wearable breast pump designed for comfort and discreet pumping.

• Powerful Suction: With suction up to -300 mmHg, it offers both Stimulation and Expression modes, each featuring 10 intensity settings, allowing you to customize your pumping experience for maximum milk output.
• Quiet Operation: Thanks to noise reduction technology, you can pump quietly in open spaces, ensuring you maintain your privacy while focusing on your work.
• Convenient App Control: The "Pump with Elvie" app allows remote control, enabling you to adjust settings and track your pumping history directly from your phone, making it easy to manage your sessions on the go.
• Customizable Fit: With soft silicone nipple cushions available in three sizes, the Elvie Stride ensures a secure and comfortable fit, allowing you to pump confidently throughout your day.

3. eufy Wearable Breast Pump S1 Pro

The eufy wearable breast pump S1 Pro is tailored to meet the needs of working moms with its smart, portable, comfortable, and capable design. Whether in an office or a shared workspace, its double pumps allow you to pump efficiently and discreetly, maximizing milk output without sacrificing time.

• Long-Lasting Battery: The innovative magnetic charging case provides up to five days of battery life, ensuring reliable pumping during back-to-back meetings or travel.
• Smart App Control: The eufy Baby app and OptiRhythm™ technology allow you to quickly set your preferred modes via your phone, so you can make the most of a short lunch break or a few free minutes between tasks.
• Hospital-Grade Suction: With a hospital-grade suction at 300 mmHg suction, soft silicone, and a 105° angled flange, the S1 Pro offers a comfortable, effective pumping experience.
• Lightweight & Discreet Design: Its portable design allows for comfortable wear under clothing, enabling quiet and private pumping in shared workspaces while balancing productivity and breastfeeding.
• Easy to Clean: With only four parts to clean, the S1 Pro simplifies post-pumping maintenance, making it a hassle-free option for busy moms.

4. Freemie Liberty II Deluxe Breast Pump System

The Freemie Liberty II Deluxe Breast Pump System is designed for working moms who need power and versatility.

• Customizable Suction: With suction up to 280 mmHg and independent controls for suction and cycle, you can customize your pumping sessions to your preference.
• Turbo® Power and Convenient Features: Its Turbo® power delivers a boost for effective milk expression, while the adjustable sleep timer and memory settings add convenience.
• Automatic Shutoff: The automatic shutoff feature ensures safety, giving you peace of mind while you focus on your tasks without worrying about your pump.
• Clear Display: The easy-to-read LCD screen provides clear information at a glance, making it simple to monitor your settings and track your pumping sessions, even on the go.

Best Electric Breast Pumps for Working Moms

5. Spectra S1 Plus:

The Spectra S1 Plus is the perfect blend of flexibility and powerful suction, making it ideal for moms who need to pump frequently while on the go.

• Strong Suction: It offers both single and double pumping capabilities, with a vacuum suction that goes up to level 12 (270 mmHg), providing strong and efficient expression.
• Portable Design and Convenient Features: Weighing only 3 pounds, it's lightweight and easy to transport. The built-in night light and LCD screen add convenience, especially for nighttime pumping.
• Whisper-Quiet Operation: Operating at a quiet 45 decibels, it's discreet enough for a work environment.
• Hygienic Closed System Design: The closed system design prevents backflow, ensuring hygiene.

6. Motif Luna Battery Powered Breast Pump

The Motif Luna, with its strong hospital-grade suction and portable design, is the perfect solution for busy moms, allowing easy use at the office or while running errands.

• Hospital-Grade Suction: Equipped with hospital-grade suction, the Luna ensures strong and efficient milk expression.
• Convenient Nighttime Pumping: The built-in LED night light and backlit LCD screen make it easy to pump during low-light conditions.
• Long Battery Life: With 2+ hours of battery life between charges, it's perfect for moms on the go—whether at the office, running errands, or traveling.
• Quiet Operation and Hygienic Design: The pump's 43-decibel hum ensures quiet operation, allowing you to pump discreetly in any environment. The backflow protection feature maintains hygiene, giving you peace of mind.

Best Manual Breast Pumps for Working Moms：

7. Dr. Brown’s Manual Breast Pump

Dr. Brown's Manual Breast Pump offers a comfortable and flexible pumping experience thanks to its SoftShape Shield, made from 100% silicone.

• Dual Expression Modes: With two expression modes for quick letdown and relaxed pumping, you can adjust to your needs for maximum efficiency.
• Portability: It's discreet and portable, ideal for working moms with its compact, travel-friendly design.
• User-Friendly Features: The curved handle and stable bottle base make it easy to use, while the all-in-one system includes a bottle, slow-flow nipple, and cap for added convenience.
• Easy Cleaning and Safety: Cleaning is simple, with dishwasher and sterilizer-safe parts. Made from BPA-free materials, this pump combines comfort, convenience, and safety.

8. Medela Harmony Manual breast pump with Flex Shields

Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump with Flex Shields is a lightweight and discreet option for working moms.

• Flex Technology: Featuring a 105-degree angle breast shield with a soft rim and oval shape, this pump improves comfort and promotes better milk flow.
• Two-Phase Expression Technology: Simulating natural baby sucking with letdown and expression phases, it efficiently collects milk to fit your pumping routine.
• Complete Pumping Kit: The package includes a 24mm PersonalFit Flex Shield, a 5oz/150mL bottle, and extra parts, providing a complete set for pumping on the go.
• Easy Maintenance: This manual pump is easy to operate and clean, with simple assembly for busy schedules.

Expert Tips for Pumping at Work

Pumping at work can come with various challenges, but with the right preparation and strategies, it can become more manageable and less stressful. For first-time moms returning to work, expert Jessica Anderson (MA, IBCLC, CLC) offers practical advice. She emphasizes starting to use the breast pump and ensuring a proper flange fit a few weeks before returning to work. Jessica also recommends helping the baby gradually get used to bottle feeding and advises pumping every 2-3 hours for 15-30 minutes to match the baby’s intake. Additionally, she shares guidelines for milk storage, reminding moms to keep milk cold and to follow storage guidelines based on location and the baby’s health.

Additional Tips

• Choose the Right Containers: Use BPA-free, leak-proof storage bags designed for breast milk or sterile glass/plastic bottles with tight-fitting lids.
• Labeling for Safety: Always label milk containers with the date and time of expression to use the oldest milk first. Track storage duration with stickers to avoid spoilage.
• Keep a Spare Set of Supplies: Store a backup set of pump parts, breast pads, and bottles at work to cover any mishaps or forgotten items.
• Transporting Milk Safely: Use an insulated cooler bag with ice packs during your commute to keep the milk at or below 40°F (4°C). Ensure all containers are securely sealed to prevent leakage.
• Stay Hydrated and Energized: Drink plenty of water and keep nutritious snacks handy to support your energy levels and milk supply.
• Dress for Convenience: Wear clothing that allows easy access for pumping. Consider outfits with zippers or buttons that make it simple to pump without feeling overly exposed.
• Communicate with Your Employer: Discuss your pumping needs openly with your employer to ensure you have the necessary time and space for pumping.

Expert Tips for Working Moms Dealing with Milk Undersupply

Some new moms may find that their milk supply decreases after returning to work, making it difficult to meet their baby's needs. To help address this issue, expert Jessica also offers some professional advice for moms dealing with milk undersupply.

1.Ensure Proper Stimulation

• Milk supply depends on proper stimulation, so try to maintain a regular breastfeeding or pumping schedule. Jessica mentions that the average stimulation needed to produce a full milk supply is between 8-12 times a day. Alternating between breasts during feeding can also help promote balanced milk production.

2. Optimize Your Breast Pump

• Invest in a high-quality breast pump and try techniques like gently massaging your breasts while pumping to help with milk flow.

3. Schedule Your Pumping Routine

• Try to schedule pumping breaks at work and discuss your needs with HR or your supervisor for support.

4. Seek Help from a Lactation Consultant

• A lactation consultant can provide personalized guidance on boosting supply, ensuring your pump is properly fitted, and troubleshooting specific challenges.

5. Maximize Your Breastfeeding at Typical Sessions

• Milk supply is typically higher in the early morning and before bedtime. So, try to breastfeed or pump at the two sessions can help boost your overall milk output.

6. Stay Positive and Seek Support When Necessary

• Balancing work with breastfeeding is no easy feat. It is advisable to connect with other working moms or join breastfeeding support groups for encouragement and advice. Remember, you are not alone, and taking care of your emotional health is vital.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while working moms face significant challenges in breastfeeding, understanding their needs and available resources can help. By choosing the right equipment and utilizing expert strategies for pumping, storage, and self-care, mothers can balance their professional lives with breastfeeding. Embracing flexibility and prioritizing self-care empowers working moms to nourish their babies while thriving in their careers. With the right tools and resilience, they can navigate this journey successfully.

FAQs

What is the best breast pump to use while working?

For working mothers, the ideal breast pump balances efficiency with convenience. An electric pump is highly efficient, while a manual pump can be quieter and more portable, fitting easily into a workday routine. Consider a model with discreet carrying options and simple assembly for ease of use between tasks.

How many times a day do working moms pump?

The frequency of pumping varies depending on the mother's milk supply and work schedule. Typically, working moms pump every 2-4 hours to maintain milk production. This could mean 2-3 times during a standard workday, including breaks and lunch hours. It's important to establish a consistent pumping schedule to support your breastfeeding goals and communicate with your employer to ensure you have the necessary time and space for pumping.